Skip to content
Article

Claude Sheets vs Excel: the office suite is surrounded, not replaced

Claude Sheets and Businesses in ChatGPT landed on the same day. What it means for Excel, Copilot, Sheets and Gemini, and how enterprises should respond.

Paper-cut collage on a near-black background. A blank ruled sheet on an orange backing sits at the centre, tied by orange threads to hands cut from orange, black and white paper that reach in from every edge and pull it in different directions, with rippling layers of dark paper edged in orange spreading out around it.

Two launches landed overnight in Melbourne. Anthropic now has a spreadsheet. So is Excel finished?

No. And I think it’s the wrong question.

The question I’d put to any enterprise is simpler and harder. When the AI vendor also hosts the document, where does the source of truth live?

What actually shipped

On 10 November (US time, early on the 11th here), Anthropic launched Claude Sheets and Claude Whiteboards in beta, and made Claude Data (formerly Dashboards) generally available.

Sheets is a spreadsheet built into Claude. You and Claude edit the same cells, and each edit Claude makes is outlined as it lands. Formulas stay in the cells, so you can check how a number was built.

Anthropic is refreshingly honest about the scope. Its announcement says sheets have “simple spreadsheet functionality” for now. When you need “the full functionality of Excel”, it tells you to export to .xlsx or CSV, or use Claude for Excel.

The help article spells out the limits. A sheet holds up to 100,000 cells. There are no pivot tables yet. Macros, VBA, Power Query and DAX aren’t supported. Sheets can’t pull live data from connected apps. And because it’s a beta, “HIPAA, CMEK, and ZDR are not yet supported.”

Official launch demo from Anthropic’s Claude channel on YouTube.

The same day, OpenAI introduced Businesses in ChatGPT, also in beta. Businesses can claim and verify a profile, manage their details and product feeds in Business Hub, and see aggregated insights on mentions and clicks. Eligible firms can publish a Business Agent that answers customer questions in a clearly labelled chat. For now, Business Agents are limited to eligible ecommerce and online-service businesses in the United States.

OpenAI’s closer answer to an office suite came earlier. ChatGPT Space and Pages arrived at DevDay on 29 September. Native Sheets in Space are still “coming soon”, according to OpenAI’s help centre.

Claude wants the workbook. ChatGPT wants the customer.

Side by side, they’re two different bets.

Anthropic is pulling the artefacts of knowledge work into Claude: docs, slides, boards, sheets and dashboards. Its pitch is that context carries “from a whiteboard to a spreadsheet to a dashboard, without the need to reiterate the details.” That’s a bid to be the place work starts and stays.

OpenAI, the same day, pulled commercial intent into ChatGPT. Claim your brand, feed your catalogue, let an agent talk to the buyer. That’s not an Excel competitor. It’s closer to a storefront inside the assistant.

Now in beta: Businesses in ChatGPT. Claim your business, manage your information, and get insights on how people engage with you.

OpenAI (@OpenAI) on X, 10 November 2026 (US time)

They barely collide on features. They collide as platforms. Both want to be the window you open first.

Surrounded, not replaced

So what does this mean for Microsoft and Google?

Less than the headlines suggest, for now. They still own the grid finance runs on, along with identity, sharing and records retention. Their answer is AI inside that grid, not a new grid.

Copilot in Excel works in edit, plan and chat modes, and in edit mode it changes the workbook directly, PivotTables included. Gemini in Google Sheets can build pivot tables and query BigQuery through Connected Sheets.

Then there’s the detail that breaks the tidy “Anthropic versus Microsoft” story. Microsoft already offers Claude as a model choice inside Excel, with a commercial Copilot subscription or Microsoft 365 Premium, once an admin enables Anthropic as a subprocessor. You can have Claude’s reasoning without leaving the file.

That’s what I mean by surrounded. The incumbents aren’t losing the grid. They’re losing the monopoly on where work starts. A tracker that used to begin as a blank workbook might now begin as a prompt, and only reach Excel when someone needs pivots or an audit trail.

Is that a threat? Over time, yes. Every artefact that starts outside the suite is one the suite has to win back.

What I’d tell a client deciding now

For most enterprises the answer will be “and”, not “or”. The work is deciding which job goes where.

Keep the source of truth where your controls are

If a number ends up in a board pack, a regulatory return or an audit file, it belongs in the governed workbook, or better, the governed data platform behind it. Use Claude Sheets or a ChatGPT Page for greenfield trackers and workshop drafts. Export before a file becomes evidence.

The cell cap and missing pivots make this easy for finance today. The hard cases are the small trackers that quietly turn into systems.

Govern it before your people find it

Check your defaults. On Claude Team plans, Sheets is on by default. On Enterprise it stays off until an admin turns it on. The ChatGPT for Excel add-in is off by default on Enterprise too.

The add-ins deserve their own review. Anthropic says Claude for Excel doesn’t inherit custom data-retention settings and its activity isn’t in Enterprise audit logs, though sessions are covered by the Compliance API where that’s enabled. It also warns about prompt injection in untrusted workbooks. How many files from outside your organisation get opened in Excel every day?

Ask where the data sits

This is where Australian enterprises need to slow down.

  • Anthropic’s privacy centre says commercial traffic may be routed to countries including Australia by default, unless otherwise agreed, but that “data is stored in the US.”
  • OpenAI lets new eligible ChatGPT Enterprise and Edu workspaces store content at rest in Australia, but doesn’t offer inference residency here. Beta features aren’t eligible for residency at all.
  • Microsoft keeps Copilot interaction content in line with your tenant’s geography. I couldn’t confirm from a current Microsoft page that Copilot inference stays in Australia, so I wouldn’t assume it.
  • Google Workspace offers data-region settings on Business Standard, Enterprise and some other editions, but the only locations are the United States or Europe (or no preference), so there’s no Australian option. I couldn’t confirm where Gemini processing happens for Australian tenants, so ask.

None of this is a blocker on its own. It’s a question for your privacy and risk teams before the pilot, not after.

Plan the exit on day one

Lock-in here is less about file formats and more about where the artefact lives. Claude Sheets exports to .xlsx and CSV, and its “Send to” option reaches partners such as Airtable, Asana, monday.com and Smartsheet. But live data and some Excel features won’t make the round trip. Test the export with a synthetic file before anyone depends on it.

The same goes for the model. If Claude runs inside Excel and inside its own app, the model is becoming portable. Keep your prompts, checks and data definitions outside any one vendor. I’ve written about routing work between frontier and open models, and the same logic applies here.

Pilot with criteria, not enthusiasm

A pilot worth running has a short scorecard:

  • Synthetic or public data only. Nothing from clients.
  • One real workflow, run in the incumbent tool and the new one.
  • Correctness checked against an answer key, not a demo.
  • Can a third person audit the formulas without reading the chat?
  • What broke on export?
  • Who owns the artefact when the pilot ends?

And count review time as cost. An answer someone has to check twice isn’t cheap, which is the point I made about what one AI agent task actually costs.

What I’m watching

  • Claude Sheets leaving beta, and whether pivots, live data and ZDR arrive with it.
  • Native Sheets actually shipping in ChatGPT Space.
  • Business Agents reaching Australian businesses.
  • Whether Microsoft confirms in-country Copilot inference here.

What I’d tell another practitioner

Don’t sell your client a winner. Sell them a map.

Excel and Google Sheets stay the system of record for anything that gets audited. Claude Sheets and ChatGPT Pages are good places to start work, and the export button is part of the design, not a failure.

Businesses in ChatGPT is a brand and marketing decision, not an analyst one. Put it on the marketing team’s list, not the data team’s.

And ask the residency question in the first meeting. For an Australian enterprise, it decides how far a pilot can go.

~ Mr. Gómez